The panel in charge of the UN's carbon offsetting scheme the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) has again rejected applications from a number of wind energy projects as it seeks to bolster confidence in the controversial scheme.
The CDM, which works by allowing emission reduction projects in developing countries to sell carbon credits, has been widely criticised by green groups for approving projects such as wind farms and clean coal plants that would have gone ahead anyway without the extra revenue generated by selling certified emission reduction (CER) credits.
The CDM's Executive Board appeared to respond to the criticism late last year, rejecting applications from 10 Chinese wind farms on the grounds that they could operate profitably without the right to issue CERs. The decision followed concerns that officials in Beijing had reduced their own incentives for wind farms as a result of the support developers were receiving through the CDM.
The affair took another twist late last week when the latest meeting of the Executive Board said that it had mistakenly included two wind farms in the list of rejected applications that should have been approved.
However, in a sign that the apparent crackdown on projects that fail to meet so-called additionality criteria is continuing, the board approved 32 Chinese wind farms for inclusion in the CDM but blocked a further six projects from entering the scheme.
Five of the six rejected projects were in the province of Heilongjiang, and according to project operators they would have generated 2.1 million CERs by 2012. According to Reuters reports, the projects' investors included US investment bank Goldman Sachs, Japanese government agency NEDO, Dutch firm Essent Energy Trading and UK-based Climate Change Capital.
The move is likely to further anger carbon traders and investors, who last year criticised the CDM in a report from the International Emission Trading Association (IETA) which warned the CDM was "buckling under the weight of its own success" and called on the UN to expand the body managing the scheme.
The group's calls for an increase in resources to manage the CDM will have also been further fuelled by the Executive Board's admission late last week that a number of key policy issues, including methodologies for assessing emission from grid power and proposals to streamline registration processes for projects were not completed due to "time constraints".
Anger over decision to bar 10 Chinese wind energy projects from entering UN-approved carbon offset scheme 07 Dec 2009
But expert warns UN offset market could still be heading for investment crisis 23 Dec 2009
Negotiations back underway as Danish hosts signal that talks should proceed based on UN draft texts 17 Dec 2009
Credibility of CDM receives yet another blow as major auditing firm is suspended 30 Mar 2010
Recession and post-Kyoto uncertainty lead to fewer UN-backed emission-reduction projects 03 Aug 2009
Power supplier urges companies with complex or foreign ownership structures to engage with the Environment Agency immediately 30 Jul 2010
Danish firm’s swan song gives way to new turbine blade maker on Isle of Wight 30 Jul 2010
Memorandum signed with Energy Department to use more renewables 30 Jul 2010
More news
Energy analyst's report questions wisdom of DECC’s energy review 29 Jul 2010
Telecity becomes 300th organisation to get the Trust’s official stamp for ongoing carbon reduction 28 Jul 2010
The price of decarbonising versus the price of business as usual: both are variables 28 Jul 2010 More in-depth
